Bahnsen on D'Souza and Catholic Protestants November 27, 2010
This is my opportunity to introduce my friend David Bahnsen to Blue Kennel readers. I
myself happened to be under the impression that before D”Souza relocated to NYC he was in fact attending an evangelical megachurch in San Diego. But be that as it may. Yes, the Protestants mostly abandoned the Protestant “world and life view” for what I have called Great Commission Utilitarianism, the belief that the occupations of ordinary life mainly exist to support the so-called Great Commission, whether narrowly or holistically conceived. And Catholics, especially Jose Maria Escriva”, the founder of Opus Dei, have moved in the other direction. (May I take this opportunity to plug the forthcoming film There Be Dragons, about a fictitious character who is a boyhood friend of Escriva” but ends up as a Franco supporter though his attitude is more Randian.) Catholics would sometimes argue that it is their online casino view of transubstantiation that leads them to a Protestant-like world and life view, even more than the Protestants; if the elements really, really become the body and blood of Christ, then Christ obviously cares about material reality and is “in the universe business,” as Bahnsen and I would put it. And in a previous post I admitted that my difficulties with transubstantiation, and the original Protestant difficulty with transubstantiation, were not with transubstantiation itself, but with the priestly class that was apparently needed to mediate grace. If the elements truly become the body and blood of the Lord under the appearance of bread and wine in response to the faith of the believer, not the presence of a properly ordained member of a priestly class supposedly mediating grace, I would really not have a lot of trouble with transubstantiation! Anyhow, the fact is that with some noble exceptions Catholics have been doing better work than Protestants on “Protestant ” world and life view issues in the last few years. The proper response of Protestants to this should not be complaining, but repentance.